- M S
Mackenzie ShirillaSelf
- T T
Tim TroupSelf - Assistant Prosecutor
- R G
Rosie GrahamSelf - Friend
- B T
Bubba TurnerSelf - Friend
- F W
Faythe WalshSelf - Childhood Friend
- S S
Steve ShirillaSelf - Mackenzie's Father
- N S
Natalie ShirillaSelf - Mackenzie's Mother
- F R
Frank RussoSelf - Dominic's Father
- C R
Christy RussoSelf - Dominic's Mother
- A R
Angelo RussoSelf - Dominic's Brother
- C R
Christine RussoSelf - Dominic's Sister
- D F
Davyne FlanaganSelf - Davion's Sister
- S F
Scott FlanaganSelf - Davion's Father
- J F
Jaime FlanaganSelf - Davion's Mother
- D R
Dominic RussoSelf (archive footage)
- D F
Davion FlanaganSelf (archive footage)
- E R
Elliot RawsonSelf - Ohio State Highway Patrol
- R F
Ryan FoxSelf - Ohio State Highway Patrol
- J M
James McDonnellSelf - Mackenzie Shirilla's Lawyer
- N M
Nancy M. RussoSelf - Judge
- C M
Christopher MartinSelf - Christy Russo's Friend
